Saturday, July 19, 2008

Are Shapiro, Wedge to blame? One strong argument says no

Tribe fans - much like all fans - like to point fingers when things are going poorly.

The biggest targets seem to be Tribe GM Mark Shapiro and manager Eric Wedge.

I guess there's no surprise there.

But Brian La Shier, one of my partners at MVN's Tribe Report says dropping the blame for this year's fiasco in the laps of GM Mark Shapiro and Eric Wedge is unfair.

"I was asked to compile a review of Cleveland’s front office and coaching staff. That sounded easy enough at first considering all the poor decisions, botched trades, and managerial shenanigans. The more I thought about it though, the more I realized that Shapiro and Wedge really aren’t to blame for the season getting off track so dramatically. Some of the more pessimistic fans in the crowd might want to sit this post out because (gasp!) this team was managed much better than their place in the standings would indicate."

Read the rest of Brian's comments here, in the final installment of MVN's three-part series looking at the Tribe's first half.

Meantime, the second-half of the season has gotten off to a pretty rotten start. Aaron Laffey was awful, allowing eight runs in 3 2/3 innings in Seattle Friday night, although five of the runs were unearned.

While that bothers me, a couple of other things bother me more.

David Dellucci was in the frickin' lineup again tonight. There is just no logical reason for him to be there. He's been awful, and he has no role in the future. His appearances at DH are taking ABs away from Ryan Garko and others - at-bats they need to prove that they either belong in the big leagues, or they don't.

Every decision made from here on in must be made with next year in mind. I don't see how Dellucci playing contributes to that goal.

The other thing that bugs me is the statue-like play of Jhonny Peralta at short. It was his booting of a routine groundball that opened the floodgates for the five unearned runs off of Laffey in the second. Peralta and Marte should be splitting 3B to see if either is a viable alternative there for next year, while Asdrubal Cabrera should be given the chance to make a bid for the 2009 shortstop job.

I have to admit with the four Tribeless days completed, I was looking forward to things getting started again so we could start watching the "next-year" folks - Marte at 3B, Cabrera as SS, Peralta at 3B, Raffy Perez as closer.

These moves make sense to me, but I'm not sure the powers that be see it the same way. For them - for some reason - it's important to get David Dellucci some more at bats.

7 comments:

the moose said...

YES - they misjudged talent. Did they really think delucci, micheals, etc were going to do the job.

Did they think all the stars would align like 2007 with no injuries and everybody performing at expected levels or better.

Look at all the BAD moves they made
They had no insurance for 2008.

They got to take the blmae just like they take the credit -They did nothing in the off season

the moose said...

please explain why a young OF who has an 8 game hitting streak is given a day off after a 4 day break. Oh thats right we need to give david delucci some bats !!!!

Isnt it up a double standard when the manager says "garko is not playing cause he is not hitting" but we need to franklin gutierrez cause he is NOT hitting

the moose said...

one more thing -I will give shapiro for NOT signing the famous carlos silva for 8,250,000 million
like seattle did - 4-11 with a 5.5 ERA yikes

the moose said...

shapiro cudos

the moose said...

one more thing - cabrera is over weight but peralta is in great shape

johnny is eric's boy

davemanddd said...

the only reason they would want to play david de-douche-bag is for a showcase to maybe squeak a trade out of a national league contender desperate for a left-handed bat and that's it. the problem with doing that is de-douche-bag just keeps lowering his trade value even lower every time he plays. i say let him play up until the deadline and then if he's still with the team, either cut him and eat the rest of his salary or turn him into aaron boone circa 2006 who played even less than what andy marte has this year in the 2nd half of that season.

Ron Vallo said...

Even if dellucci hits .750 between now and July 31, trading partners won;t forget his body of work to this point.

I assume you're right about why he's being played but in the end it won't make a difference.

Given the reason he's playing, the trading deadline can;t come soon enough.