Andy MartEE is seeking the final spot among the position players on the Tribe's roster. With the Tribe tabbing Jorge Julio for a spot in the pen and sending Scott Elarton to Buffalo today, newly arrived lefty reliever Craig Breslow is in a similar situation out in the pen - battling Tom Mastny for the last musical chair out there.
Both MartEE and Breslow are out of options, meaning they would be subjected to waivers if the Tribe tried to send them to the minors.
That fact is not hurting their chances of making the final cut. Neither is Breslow's left-handedness or the late-innings heroics from both players today.
MartEE hit a three-run shot today to put the Tribe ahead to stay in the eight inning of their 7-5 win over the Yankees. Breslow, making his Tribe debut, pitched a perfect ninth inning, striking out two and picking up a save.
MartEE's homer helped the troubled infielder make up for two more errors in today's game, giving him six for the spring.
When he arrived in the Coco Crisp deal, MartEE was considered a top-notch third baseman.
With his awful spring in the field this year, you have to assume that MartEE's confidence has taken a nosedive or that he has been confused and distracted by the Tribe's efforts to turn him into a utility player, working him out at 1B and in the outfield.
MartEE also came with the reputation of being a potential impact hitter, albeit one who is streaky.
He sure has been just that this spring.
He has five homers in Florida. But if you eliminate today's game, and a game against Washington in which he hit two homers and had six RBIs, MartEE is hitting .204 this spring. A guy who can't play one position in the field, let-alone several, and who is a streaky hitter unlikely to do well coming off the bench cold, is not an ideal candidate for the utility player role. But that is what you are likely to see with MartEE. You have to assume Breslow will get a couple more innings in the Tribe's last four games to give the Tribe's brass something to go on. But his trump card is the team's desire to give Eric Wedge two lefties to play with out of the bullpen. The roster had been expected to be in place by Thursday, when the Tribe breaks camp. But Wedge now says final roster decisions may not come until this weekend.
So maybe it's not as cut-and-dried as it seems.
EDITOR'S NOTE:
Tribe Fan in Yankeeland is now picked up by the national sports Web site Yardbarker.com. Sees our stories as well as countless others on the Tribe at YardBarker's Indians page, as well as stories on all sports from thousands of contributors around the country at YardBarker's home page.
Those of you who drafted Aaron Fultz as the sleeper lefty for you fantasy team, time to pull the plug.The Tribe realized it was plug-pulling time today, telling the lefty reliever he would not make the 25-man roster.
They will either eat his $1.5 million salary or designate and trade him.
Fultz was somewhat useful as a lefty out of the pen in the early part of last season, until a pulled muscle in his rib cage kept him out of action for five weeks. After that he was, at best, unreliable. (I'm in a mood to be kind).
This spring he was just plain awful.
I'm fine with the decision to cut Fultz.
It's the decision on how to replace him that I'm not sure about.
Craig Breslow, put on waivers by the Red Sox and picked up by the Tribe yesterday, is expected to be handed a spot on the roster - primarily because he is left-handed.
He's already 27 and has had only two cups of coffee in the majors.
The Tribe hasn't said Breslow will make the club for sure, but you don't pick up a guy in the last week of spring training with no minor league options left, and then create a hole in your bullpen, unless you're planning to hand the job to the guy you just picked up.
I can't comment with any degree of credibility on Breslow, since I know virtually nothing about him beyond what the numbers tell us.
Breslow went 2-3 with a 4.06 ERA in 49 games for Triple-A Pawtucket last year. He struck out 73 and walked 25 in 68 2/3 innings pitched.I can say this. I work with lots of Red Sox fans and they all snickered when mentioning the Tribe's pickup of Breslow.
I guess we'll find out soon enough.
The final spot in the pen will go to Tom Mastny, Scott Elarton or Jorge Julio.
My money is on Julio for his back-of-the pen experience.Meanwhile, the Tribe did make a final decision on its starting rotation.
Cliff Lee - as expected - took the fifth spot, with Aaron Laffey and Jeremy Sowers headed for Buffalo.Still, Mark Shapiro remains impressed with Laffey:"When he came into camp this year, it was the first time he came in with expectations and people knowing who he was. It took him a while to get comfortable with that. As he got comfortable in camp, he was the same guy, just throwing ground balls, relying on his strengths and competitiveness."Ditto Jeremy Sowers:
"It was as good an arm strength as we've seen. His command of his secondary pitches needs to keep getting better. If it does, we have a guy who can definitely impact our big league rotation this year. I'm really excited about where Jeremy is right now."
The good news is the Tribe is at least seven-deep in starters, while the big bashers from Motown are having trouble finding five guys to throw out there.
One of the few things about being in Yankeeland is that the winters here aren't quiet as rough as in Cleveland, and seem to break a little earlier,I don't think ever - in the 24 years I've lived here - have we had snow on Easter.So for those of you living in the homeland, sorry about that!I guess if you have to have snow it's better on Easter than on Opening Day, no?There finally is some good news on the fifth-starter front. Cliff Lee, with his five scoreless innings Saturday seems to have stepped to the forefront and now seems like the likely No. 5 starter. Lee, just a couple of seasons away from Cy Young consideration , has had trouble nailing down the spot.Lee of course is competing with youngsters Aaron Laffey and Jeremy Sowers for the spinal spot in the Tribe rotation.Laffey had a solid outing in his most-recent Florida start and they say Sowers is back up over 90 mph.Since Lee has had considerable success in the past, I think it makes sense to give him the spot in the rotation. His spring has been as up-and-down as Laffey's and Sowers', and with the three of them picking it up lately it just makes sense to have Lee start the season on the Tribe's roster with the other two ready to take over if he falters.
A new armThe Indians picked up a 27-year-old career minor leaguer off waivers today, and his presence may be a threat to Aaron Fultz.The new arrival is Craig Breslow, who was let go by the Red Sox. He's out of options and would have to make the Tribe's 25-man roster if they are to keep him.Breslow went 2-3 with a 4.06 ERA in 49 games at Pawtucket last year. He struck out 73 batters and walked 25 in 68 2/3 innings pitched.Fultz, who was just OK prior to his arm injury last year and pretty much a disaster after coming back, is having an awful spring. The Tribe seems married to the idea of having two lefties in the pen. Raffie Perez will be the main guy and - until today - it seemed Fultz had a spot wrapped up.Tom Mastny, Jorge Julio and Scott Elarton - all right handers - are vying for the final spot assuming the Tribe insists on keeping two lefties.I've said it before, I wouldn't mind seeing two of those three make the cut.