Saturday, May 31, 2008

Doom and gloom over Pronk's injury

The Plain Dealer Web site is reporting that Travis Hafner's shoulder problems may bring a premature end to the big DH's season.

A cortisone shot - the third this season - apparently did not help ease the pain in Hafner's shoulder and the vague "weakness" in the joint that he describes apparently has not gotten any better either with a few days off.

With a stint on the DL, Hafner will have at least 10 days to work to strengthen the shoulder. If rest doesn't help, Hafner's season could be in jeopardy. Or so says the PD.

Certainly not good news. Just as losing a potential lights-out arm for the pen - Adam Miller - is certainly not good news, and much worse news than the ho-hum reception it has gotten by the fans and the media.

Still the news of Hafner's shelving is not quite as bad as it's made out to be by the PD's Paul Hoynes:

"Should that not bring Travis Hafner's sore right shoulder around, perhaps the Indians will have to raise the white flag on a season that keeps getting worse the deeper they get into it."

I'm not one of those bloggers who sits around in his bathrobe in his mother's basement hurling insults at members of the mainstream media. In fact, in my day job I am a member of the mainstream media.

I'm simply stating that in this case Hoynes is going well overboard.

Perhaps it should signal to the Tribe that they must now go out and get a bat. Despite his anemic results at the plate so far this year, Hafner's presence in the middle of the lineup did give opposing pitchers something to think about. If he is out for a lengthy period of time, or for the rest of the year, Victor Martinez may not see another decent pitch all season, unless a replacement stick is brought in.

In addition to perhaps lighting a fire in the front office about improving the offense so that pennant-winning starting pitching doesn't wilt on the vine, Hafner's absence may actually help the lineup. No longer will there be the shadow of a formerly great power hitter mucking up the middle of the order.

No one's blaming Hafner. An injury is an injury. And I'll be as happy as anyone else if/when the real Pronk - the one with a healthy shoulder and a home run cut returns.

Until then the Tribe may do better by working around the absence instead of not admitting that Hafner has been absent even though he's been here all season. That was the failed plan for the first two months of the year.

As far as throwing up the white flag, with the kind of starting pitching this team has, and with the division being what it is, the only way the Tribe is forced out of the race early is if the bullpen continues to be as unreliable as it has been.

The Tribe can play and win close, low-scoring games. But the quickest way to douse the team's hopes is to keep losing those close ones thanks to the pen.

Finally a Tribe starter gets picked up by his mates

In pretty much every game of what has been a dreadful season for the Tribe so far, the blueprint has been the same.

One of the Tribe's starters pitches his butt off, only to be let down by an impotent offense or an inept bullpen - or both.

Tonight - for a change - an Indians starter was off, but was picked up by both the offense and the pen.

Cliff Lee, who has pitched like a Cy Young candidate until his last two outings, gave up 4 runs on 10 hits tonight over 6 innings. Keeping the Royals to just four runs under the circumstance was a moral victory of sorts for Lee.

But he also got a real victory as well, the tangible kind that shows up on the stat sheet and in the standings, and it had mostly to do with a bullpen that got the job done for three innings and an offense that popped three long balls - two by Grady Sizemore and one by Casey Blake.

The 8 hits by the Tribe overall weren't much to write home about, but the extra-base hit (in this case lots of extra bases) seems to be making a bit of a comeback for the Tribe in recent days.

The Tribe's outfield defense was outstanding tonight, particularly late in the game.

Ben Francisco made a behind-the-runner throw to nip David DeJesus at second base as he was rounding the bag on a single to right field. The out was made a second or so before Joey Gathright, who had been on second to start the play, was able to cross the plate - eliminating his would-be game-tying run.

In the seventh, Franklin Gutierrez, who had taken over in right field that inning, made a diving catch with two outs to save a run - again the would-be tying run.

In the ninth, Sizemore ended the ballgame with a run- and game-saving catch - slamming into the wall in left-center and preserving a save for Joe Borowski.

It's safe to say the Tribe hitters and bullpen owe the starters a lot more than one.

Let's hope this is the beginning of a long period of payback.

---

Travis Hafner went on the DL today, finally giving in to the shoulder problems that have plagued him since the middle of spring training.

We've said this before. It bears repeating.

This is now the second key player - Borowski being the first - that the Tribe allowed to play through injury for two months, to the detriment of the team and the player.

Let's hope the time off will strengthen the shoulder and clear the head of Travis Hafner and that he can come back in a couple of weeks and contribute the way he should.

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

My nightly rant about the Tribe

Some are taking solace in the fact that the Tribe has scored 13 runs in the last two games.

In fact they've scored 31 in the past six games, four of which they lost.

Yes the hitting seems to slowly be pulling out of its season-long futility, though there's still lots of convincing to do on that one.

Take today for instance. The game is on the line. The Tribe is down a run with one out and runners on second and third. Bottom of the ninth. Hitters No.3 and No. 4 due up. Two infield popups later (technically one was caught in short, short left) - ballgame over.

These are games the Tribe won against the White Sox last year, and against the Tigers, and against pretty much everyone else. They're the games the White Sox are winning this year, at least lately and against the Tribe.

Last year's infallible one, Raffie Betancourt, has been anything but that this year, coming in in the seventh and promptly blowing yet another lead. There's no way to sugarcoat it, Betancourt has been awful this year. He, and the rest of the bullpen, are another key reason the Tribe's not winning the games they used to win.

Things just don't seem to be in sync this year. Not all the cylinders are hitting on the same night. Or at least it is rare when the do.

While we're busy pointing fingers, it is necessary to point out that the winning three-run rally by the Sox in the seventh started on a booted ground ball by Andy Marte (who booted another one an inning later but didn't get charged with an error).

Marte doubled off the wall last night and laid down a nice bunt. He singled today, and stole the first base of his career. But he just looks so damned shaky in the field and at the plate.

I don't fault the idea of playing the youngster, and in fact applaud it, but I just don't think he's got the stomach to make it in the bigs. At the very least it seems he will never regain the confidence he needs to let his talent shine through here in Cleveland. If Marte plays more regularly it should become clear he was a mistake and the Tribe should cut their losses on him.

And while we are on the topic of front-office mistakes, for the second time in this young season the Tribe has tried to hide an injury to a key player and hope he can play through it. Instead, the players in question have underperformed miserably and the team has paid the price.

After a miserable early season outing it became obvious the Tribe could no longer hide the physical problems closer Joe Borowski was having. They started way back in spring training, but instead of shutting him down in mid-March, they had to do it during the season - after he blew a few ballgames that counted.

And now we find the situation is similar with Travis Hafner.

MLB.com's Anthony Castrovince reports the cortisone shot Hafner got was the second of the season and that the Tribe was - and still is - trying to squeeze performance out of damaged goods.

Pronk revealed that this is the second time this season he's received such an injection. He received the other before the Indians opened a three-game series in Minnesota on April 18. Hafner missed the first game of that series.

The shoulder has given Pronk problems since the middle of March. Hafner said he had an MRI exam that revealed no structural damage.- Anthony Castrovince of MLB.com

The Tribe is hoping the cortisone shot will allow Hafner to rejoin the lineup Friday, but what is to be gained by trying to force performance out of the ailing and struggling Hafner?

He and the team would be better served to if Hafner were to take some DL time to rest, and maybe get some rehab ABs in the minors, where he might be able to get himself on track.